Fiddled around a little more tonight, and can’t get past Isaac (/Isace) Keaton (/Keeton) (b 1810 VA). Spelled Isaac Keeton in the 1850 Census of Cannon County, Tenn., it says he was married to a woman named Sarah (b 1814), but I don’t know what her maiden name was. Google searches and further FamilySearch.org searches yield no results on Isaac Keaton other than the 1850 Census and record of an Isaac Keeton on the 1840 Census. So I guess I either need a death record of one of their children that has her maiden name, or I need to delve into some Virginia Censuses.
I finally found that he was buried in Missouri, in the Snodgrass Cemetery in 1858. His wife was buried in the Clifty Cemetery in 1882. This means they must have moved to Missouri in the eight years between 1850 and 1858, which is interesting.
Here are Isaac and Sarah’s children as of 1850:
- Henry N – 1833
- William I (?) – 1839
- Epraim S – 1841
- Abrahm C. – 1841
- John R. – 1845
- James L – 1848
- Larkin T – 1849
So, Findagrave.com is useful, and gave me the find of the night. This picture is supposedly of James Lennex Keaton, my great-great-great grandfather (I’ve also found spellings of “Lenox”). Not sure where how the photo was obtained, so I don’t know for sure if it is him or not. Either way, this dude is sporting a pretty badass beard and scowl combo.
My biggest concern is that James L.’s wife’s name is, I thought Martha Parmer, but he could have remarried, maybe Mary is short for Martha, or some other mid-19th century anomaly.

And now it’s 2:39 a.m., so maybe I’ll play with this more later.
Edit: I showed this picture to my great-grandfather, and he acted pretty excited about it. He confirmed that James was his grandfather, but said he never saw any of his grandparents (three of them died within a year after he was born in 1927, and the other, Louisa Lambeth Perkins, died in 1905). A guy he knew as a kid told him stories, and Grampa wishes he were still around. “I miss those old-timers.”